Talk:Pokémon 3rd Generation

Article Discussion

I agree that the different generations should be grouped together, particularly when related to hacking, but I'm not sure how. You may have noticed the many updates I've been doing on DC the last few days, especially on the Pokémon-related articles.

You can see an example of the set-up I've established here: Pokémon Second Generation (a Disambiguation page), but I'm starting to feel that the "(Official Game/s)" and "(Hacking)" differentiation isn't necessary, since it creates confusion among articles. If anything, we could remove the various "Official Game/s" and add some of that information to "(Hacking)" articles, since my point was to provide information on the actual games and their features, which you could then move over to the technical aspects of them on the "(Hacking)" articles.

I'd love to hear any opinion, since without a standard for articles I'm afraid to move on too much more. Redstar 19:27, 5 June 2009 (UTC)

You could have a part "About the game" (or in Pokémon's case "games"). For example, the page for, say, Super Mario Bros could have headers (or subpages if it's too large) with a summary of the game itself with any technical data like the NES's mapper used as before, followed by the romhacking data. --Kawa 08:25, 6 June 2009 (UTC)

Okay, I just took a look at that 2nd gen example, and that's close enough to what I just said. --Kawa 08:27, 6 June 2009 (UTC)

Looked around some more, and I stick with the idea that the Pokémon games (per generation) are too damn similar to warrant seperate pages. The specials (Yellow, Crystal, Emerald and Platinum) may be quite different, but most of that is only plot and some added content. --Kawa 08:31, 6 June 2009 (UTC)

Well what I'm thinking of doing is making only four articles, named "Pokémon First Generation", "Pokémon Second Generation", etc. Each article will have the story of the game (to differentiate from hack stories), a list of features (so hackers can get an idea of what they can work with/around), then the article will move on to the actual hacking information and deal with utilities, etc. The actual "raw" data for ROM and RAM Maps, Notes, etc. will be linked to individual articles, most of which are already created and just need updating.

My whole point in splitting the articles into (Official Games) and (Hacking) was because I wanted people to get an idea of the game from an official stand-point, then just click over to the technical information for hacking. I also wanted to put up individual histories, such as when that game first started being hacked, by who, and when breakthroughs were made. But that specifically might be hard to find information on (most hackers back then are anonymous or forgotten).

So it's either this: keep the articles split, but merge the various (Official Games) articles for one specific generation into one article and the same for the (Hacking) articles, or just merging all the information from one generation into a huge article. Redstar 08:55, 6 June 2009 (UTC)